Rating criteria

Once you know how the scores are made, the character of each product shows through the numbers.

1. There are four kinds of scores

Not every score you see on TakguLife is made the same way. The names may look similar but they mean different things, so please tell these four apart.

  • Manufacturer-published figures: performance scores a manufacturer publishes using its own method. Use them as a reference for gauging products within the same brand.
  • TakguLife common ratings: scores for product characteristics, given on common items and criteria. Use them when you compare products from different brands.
  • User star rating: the overall satisfaction left by real users. It shows the general tendency of users’ opinions.
  • User ratings by criterion: scores real users leave for individual items such as speed and spin. They help you gauge a product’s characteristics from experience.

Manufacturer figures show how a maker evaluates its own product. The common ratings give a single yardstick for comparing characteristics. User ratings show the satisfaction and impressions of people who have actually used the product.

2. Manufacturer-published figures

Some manufacturers publish performance such as speed and spin as figures of their own. These are shown only when the manufacturer has published them.

Items, scales and calculation methods differ from brand to brand, so they are not suitable for comparing products from different brands directly. For example, if brand A scores 95 for speed and brand B scores 90, you cannot say that brand A’s product is necessarily faster.

So please use the manufacturer figures to understand the characteristics of products within the same brand.

3. TakguLife common ratings

So that products from different brands can be compared, the same items are applied to every product and its characteristics are given as scores. Scores run from 1 to 10 and are shown both as a radar chart and as bar charts.

Rubbers

  • Speed: how fast the ball leaves the rubber
  • Spin: how much spin the rubber can produce
  • Control: how easy it is to send the ball where you want
  • Lightness: the lighter the rubber, the higher the score

Rackets

  • Speed: how fast the racket sends the ball on impact
  • Spin: how much spin the racket can produce
  • Control: how easy it is to send the ball where you want
  • Vibration: the vibration felt in the hand on impact. High or low is not good or bad in itself: more vibration gives a crisper feel, less vibration a duller, muted feel.

Shoes

  • Lightness: the lighter the shoe, the less weight burden on movement, and the higher the score
  • Fit: how well and how comfortably the shoe fits the foot
  • Grip: how well the shoe prevents slipping on the floor and supports stable movement

4. How should you read the scores?

A high score means that characteristic stands out relatively. It does not mean that a product with high scores in every item is the best product for every user.

A fast rubber may suit aggressive play, but some players find it harder to control. The same goes for racket vibration: a player who likes a crisp feel and a player who likes a quiet feel will rate it differently.

Use the scores as a reference for understanding a product, and think about your own skill, style of play and taste together with them.

5. How are user ratings reflected?

Scores by criterion start from our editorial team’s initial rating and gradually reflect users’ ratings.

We start with the editorial rating

At first, the editorial team sets the scores with reference to the manufacturer’s official materials and hands-on experience. These scores serve as a starting point for looking at a product’s characteristics until enough user ratings have built up. They are not precise laboratory measurements or an absolute performance standard.

It changes as user ratings build up

  • With fewer than 5 user ratings, the editorial rating is used as the basis.
  • From 5 ratings, the user average starts to be reflected.
  • As user ratings increase, the score moves closer to the user average.

In the calculation, one editorial rating carries the same weight as 18 user ratings. This is designed so that a handful of ratings cannot swing a score wildly, while the opinions of real users count for more once enough ratings have accumulated.

Star ratings and per-criterion scores are different

The overall star rating is the average of the overall stars left by users, and it does not include the editorial rating. Per-criterion scores start from the editorial team’s initial rating, and the weight of user ratings grows little by little.

6. Why is rubber hardness hard to compare directly?

The way rubber hardness is measured and the standard used can differ by manufacturer and by region. So even if two brands publish the same hardness number, it is hard to say the two feel equally firm.

TakguLife shows the hardness numbers manufacturers publish as they are. Use hardness as a reference for comparing products within the same brand, and when comparing across brands, look at how the rubber actually feels and at user ratings too.

7. How to make use of the scores

Rather than adding up every item or choosing by the highest numbers, it works better to decide first which items matter most to you.

  • If you like fast attack, look mainly at speed and spin.
  • If stable rallying matters, look at control.
  • If you want light equipment, check lightness.
  • If feel matters, look at a racket’s vibration characteristic together with what other players say.

The radar chart is good for seeing the balance of a product’s characteristics at a glance, and the bar charts and comparison table help you check differences item by item. Add other players’ real experience and you can learn things the numbers alone cannot tell you.

8. The limits of the ratings, honestly

TakguLife’s ratings are a reference to help you choose equipment. They are not the result of testing every product precisely in the same environment, and they do not describe every characteristic of a product perfectly.

In particular, the initial per-criterion scores start from our editorial judgment, so please treat them as a reference until enough user ratings have built up. User ratings also vary with the individual’s skill and taste, the other equipment used, and the playing environment.

Rather than deciding between products on a single score, please consider the specs, the ratings, other players’ experience and your own style of play together. And if you have used a product, please leave a star rating and per-criterion scores. Your participation makes these scores more accurate.

How to leave a rating is described in How to use.